Picked Off: The NHL All-Star Draft
As I was driving around Boston earlier this week listening to the 98.5 (THE SPORTS HUUUBB!) I heard a commercial for the NHL All-Star game being played this Sunday. With only two Bruins in the game and Sidney Crosby boycotting like a child due to concussions despite sharing a locker room with the disgraceful Matt Cooke, I hadn’t been paying much attention. Then the final line of the commercial caught my attention: the teams this year would not be East vs. West, or even North America vs. The World (which I kind of liked) but picked by two captains (hometown rep Eric Staal and Niklas Lidstrom) like they were back in the schoolyard at recess.
I went from a 1 to Girl Scout Cookie Delivery Day on the scale of excitedness. Not only were they picking teams (meaning someone has to be picked last) but they were televising the draft on Versus Friday night. Despite the fact that hockey players are generally an unsmiling, humorless bunch, this promised to be entertaining television.
The first thing I noticed is just that: captains, the already-picked, the waiting-to-be-picked —nobody looks like they want to be there. It’s as if Gary Bettman sat them down and said, “Look, our ratings suck, sure it’s gimmicky, but we need to try something, so get up there and dance for the cameras.” However, a moment later there is a sound bite of one Team Lidstrom’s players (already-picked) talking about Shea Weber’s slapshot, “He once took a clapper from between the dots…so fast…almost took my head off…I’m glad it didn’t take his head off.”
Maybe it really is just a lack of personality.
However, just as I think that, St. Louis Blues forward David Backes is interviewed and promises that if picked last, “whoever doesn’t take me is getting hit Sunday.” Like I said, this is the best idea the NHL has had since eliminating ties. There were also some amusing asides like Lidstrom deciding to pick stud Brad Richards because he texted him between rounds asking if he’d be OK playing wing instead of center, and Richards gave him the thumbs up; Flyer teammates Claude Giroux and Danny Briere betting who would be getting picked first (hopefully they wagered Sean Avery and Dion Phaneuf’s resident puck bunny Elisha Cuthbert); and a nervous Matt Duchene making an awkward “did we get voted off the island?” joke not once but twice as the remaining players available dwindled down to five.
The part of the draft that delivered best, however, is the fact that Eric Staal, in front of his hometown fans, actually picked his team as if it was a middle school kickball game while Lidstrom gladly plucked up the more talented roster. Being a Hurricanes forward, Staal, with the first pick overall, goes with Cam Ward, the Hurricanes goalie AKA the mediocre best friend that gets picked way too early because the captain doesn’t want to hurt feelings.
Meanwhile, Lidstrom waited until the fifth round to select Bruins goalie and current league leader in GAA (Goals Against Average) Tim Thomas. He then went on to select Marc Andre-Fleury (fifth in GAA) and Jonas Hiller (league leader in wins). Where does top pick Ward stack up against these guys? Twenty-eighth in GAA! Twelfth in save percentage! Seventh in wins (behind all three Lidstrom goalies)! And while Staal was picking his buddy, Lidstrom used his first pick on Steve Stamkos, who only leads the league in both goals and points.
Staal (who afterward admitted to leaning towards the “hometown boys”) also picked teammate Jeff Skinner, who at 18 is the youngest all-star ever in the history of the four major sports, AKA the kid brother who mom (the Raleigh fans) made him take. Despite having a solid season with 40 points, he has been outscored by all but one forward Lidstrom selected after Skinner was taken, including Anze Kopitar and Loui Eriksson (both with 49 points), Matt Duchene (45) and Martin Havlat (43). To put some salt in the wound, while watching Skinner approach the stage, Lidstrom mused to alternate captain Patrick Kane that he has a kid the same age.
Lidstrom also somehow managed to take the far tougher team with defensemen Duncan Keith, Weber (who fired a puck through the net at the Olympics), Keith Yandle, Brent Burns, and versatile bruiser Dustin Byfuglien. Keep in mind that Lidstrom himself will be playing for them. The only defenseman Staal took in the first six rounds is Zdeno Chara, who, while large, is not a terribly physical player considering his size. Even the rookies knew better: when given the option of representing Team Staal or Team Lidstrom during the Rookie Skill Challenge, Taylor Hall didn’t hesitate to choose Lidstrom while an unimpressed Staal looked on quietly. Hopefully this leads to Hall getting put over the boards on his next trip to Raleigh.
A perfect cap to the evening was Mr. Irrelevant, former Bruin (and reason that Tyler Seguin and next year’s Toronto lottery pick will end up in Boston) Phil Kessel, walking on stage in a dopey daze, ignoring the announcer’s pleas to join him at center stage until he’s already sitting down with the team, then randomly being presented with a new car for being picked last while the rest of the players, Daniel Sedin specifically, stare in disbelief (mind you these are hockey players who make like 1/10th of what NBA or MLB players do).
Overall, just a satisfying hour and a half of television. Hopefully the game this Sunday lives up to the draft.
*Image courtesy of Library and Archives Canada/Jules-Ernest Livernois collection/PA-024066 via Wikimedia Commons

